
So far my experience as a writing coach has been interesting, although less involved than I had anticipated it to be (at least so far). I have received responses from 3 of the 6 students I have reached out to, and the back-and-forth responding has been sporadic. That said, it has been somewhat difficult to stay on top of each writer as an individual because the timing of when I receive their writing has been alternating between student, which class they are in, and what their specific writing assignment is about. Overall, managing those nitty gritty aspects has been mildly challenging. When I have received responses, the interactions are always beneficial and constructive for myself as a writing coach and hopefully for them as the writer. Seeing as they are a handful of years younger than I am, I can visibly see the difference in exposure to writing. It’s not their fault that I am several years older and have more experience reading/writing, but their level of understanding does seem to reflect a high school level status. Some of the writers have put forth more effort than others, and that effort certainly shows in the strength of their narratives. Those that have given more time to how they want to phrase their stories have provided more to work with than those that showed minimal effort. As their coach, it has been my job to point out the areas that did work (despite the overall quality of the paper). The main thing to keep in mind is that they are not professionals and neither am I. It’s nice to be in a position to offer insight, but I have stressed in my comments to them that my comments are suggestions and not the gold standard of writing. What these writers have shown a need for is an interest in what they have to say through their writing. I have done my best to draw connections to their writing by adding personal comments about how I could see myself in their shoes in certain scenarios that they have written about. The main thing to keep in mind for me as a coach is to not be overly judgmental of their skill level. I have been more focused on getting them to expand on the thoughts and ideas that they have already expressed.
For this week’s post, I found an article from Thought Catalog titled ’10 Tips For A Novice Writer (From a Novice Writer)’. I see this article being helpful in terms of receiving concrete advice and adapting a game-plan when writing. Thanks for reading! https://thoughtcatalog.com/ayodeji-awosika/2015/07/10-tips-for-a-novice-writer-from-a-novice-writer/

Hey George!
First off: great photo! π Thanks for providing your personal experiences when it came to your students and providing great examples of what it means to give guidance or give that feedback/comment on a student’s work. Someone can easily say what it means to do so but it always help to actually give examples and provide personal experience with which anyone can learn from to enhance themselves as writing coaches, editors, etc.
-Silbi
LikeLike
You make a lot of good points, and I think we are all experiencing many of the same issues as far as communication with our assigned student writers. I have only had communication with one of my students, and it’s not very in-depth conversation either. You also mentioned the fact that you were several years older and can visibly notice the difference in your exposure to writing compared to them. Imagine how I feel. While my experience/exposure is more sporadic due to my life choices and unconventional path to the college life, I definitely understand where you are coming from. However, due to this disconnect, I feel myself also placing my focus on trying to get them to expand their thoughts more clearly.
LikeLike
Hey George,
I’m in the same boat as you and Dan regarding the inconsistency in communication with my students. Before this week, I’d only received three assignments, and the only response to my suggestions being something along the lines of “I’ve fixed it.” I was hoping for slightly more engagement with the students, and it seems that this week is providing that, as I’ve received more papers and the students seem excited to hear back from me again. Hopefully a healthy coach-trainee relationship can start to take place where we can discuss how they approach their assignments and what I could do better as a coach– I think the mutual feedback is highly beneficial.
Now that the assignments are flooding in at sporadic times, I’m also having a hard time keeping on top of which assignment is due on which date. I’m definitely reorganizing my class folder on Google Drive over the next couple of days.
LikeLike